Plush

Browse All Plush

Filter by age

  • 0-2
  • 3-5
  • 6-8
  • 9-11
  • 12+
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Sour Patch Kids Packaging Plush

    Sour Patch Kids Packaging Plush

    $42.99
    Go To Product

    Great for ages 11-12

  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Bixbie Longhorn

    Bixbie Longhorn

    $23.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Rainboba Tea Plush

    Rainboba Tea Plush

    $35.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | M&M Plush Pillow

    M&M Plush Pillow

    $42.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Mini Highland Cow

    Mini Highland Cow

    $12.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Jet-Puffed Marshmallow Plush

    Jet-Puffed Marshmallow Plush

    $42.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Purr-fect Pals Sassy Sak w/White Cat

    Purr-fect Pals Sassy Sak w/White Cat

    $23.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Baby Cuddle Hug Fawn

    Baby Cuddle Hug Fawn

    $29.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Carmine Cardinal

    Carmine Cardinal

    $11.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Oreo Cookies Packaging Plush

    Oreo Cookies Packaging Plush

    $38.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Pinkalicious Soft Doll

    Pinkalicious Soft Doll

    $38.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Dum-Dums Plush

    Dum-Dums Plush

    $42.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Chicks Assortment

    Chicks Assortment

    $10.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Smarties Candy Plush

    Smarties Candy Plush

    $44.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Pizza Rat Macaroon

    Pizza Rat Macaroon

    $15.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Colorful Chicks

    Colorful Chicks

    $12.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Sourpuss Octopus

    Sourpuss Octopus

    $32.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Sour Patch Kid Plush Blind Bag

    Sour Patch Kid Plush Blind Bag

    $7.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Western Sak w/ Buckskin Horse

    Western Sak w/ Buckskin Horse

    $23.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Pauline Spotted Pig

    Pauline Spotted Pig

    $30.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Maddie - White Bunny Softie

    Maddie - White Bunny Softie

    $23.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Mini Donut Vanilla Scented Plush

    Mini Donut Vanilla Scented Plush

    $15.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Nola Purple Mermaid

    Nola Purple Mermaid

    $17.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Rainbow Chick

    Rainbow Chick

    $10.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | LITTLE Green Plant Plush

    LITTLE Green Plant Plush

    $10.99
    Go To Product

    Great for ages 3-6

  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Natural Lil' Bitty Bunnies

    Natural Lil' Bitty Bunnies

    $8.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Flip Frog

    Flip Frog

    $12.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Serena Pink Mermaid

    Serena Pink Mermaid

    $17.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Super Soft Pinkie Pig

    Super Soft Pinkie Pig

    $37.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Nellie Horse Soft

    Nellie Horse Soft

    $21.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Natural Mini Bunny

    Natural Mini Bunny

    $14.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Petunia Ballerina Mouse

    Petunia Ballerina Mouse

    $17.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Valentines Hippo w/ Heart

    Valentines Hippo w/ Heart

    $14.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Stephanie Pink T-Rex Soft

    Stephanie Pink T-Rex Soft

    $21.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Peter Pig Muzzle

    Peter Pig Muzzle

    $12.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Fran Cowgirl Doll

    Fran Cowgirl Doll

    $26.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Large Dale Dachshund Muzzle

    Large Dale Dachshund Muzzle

    $18.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Carl Corgi Muzzle

    Carl Corgi Muzzle

    $12.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Scottie Highland Cow Softie

    Scottie Highland Cow Softie

    $23.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Valentines Capybara w/Rose

    Valentines Capybara w/Rose

    $14.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Rainbow Twizzlers Plush

    Rainbow Twizzlers Plush

    $45.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Kraft Mac & Cheese Microwave Plush

    Kraft Mac & Cheese Microwave Plush

    $33.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Tommie Baby Turtle Mini

    Tommie Baby Turtle Mini

    $15.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Fairy Friends Sassy Sak w/Fawn

    Fairy Friends Sassy Sak w/Fawn

    $23.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | George Giraffe Muzzle

    George Giraffe Muzzle

    $13.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Donut Microbead Plush

    Donut Microbead Plush

    $33.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Valentines Capy Cake

    Valentines Capy Cake

    $14.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Large Tim Tan Dog Muzzle

    Large Tim Tan Dog Muzzle

    $18.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Sour Patch Kid w/Heart Plush

    Sour Patch Kid w/Heart Plush

    $24.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Bright Mini Soft Bunny

    Bright Mini Soft Bunny

    $15.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Bobbie Chicken Soft

    Bobbie Chicken Soft

    $23.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Octavia Octopus

    Octavia Octopus

    $26.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Farm Minis Asst.

    Farm Minis Asst.

    $12.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Tumbleweed Bull

    Tumbleweed Bull

    $14.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Capybara w/ Bunny Ears

    Capybara w/ Bunny Ears

    $14.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Tie Dye Bunny Assrt.

    Tie Dye Bunny Assrt.

    $10.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Gladys Cow Muzzle

    Gladys Cow Muzzle

    $12.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Buddie Iguana Soft

    Buddie Iguana Soft

    $26.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Cowgirl Boots Sassy Sak w/Horse

    Cowgirl Boots Sassy Sak w/Horse

    $23.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Valentines Muzzle Dog

    Valentines Muzzle Dog

    $13.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Large Peter Pig Muzzle

    Large Peter Pig Muzzle

    $18.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Jorge Chestnut Horse Muzzle

    Jorge Chestnut Horse Muzzle

    $12.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Baby Ladybug Hug

    Baby Ladybug Hug

    $29.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Unicorn Sassy Sak

    Unicorn Sassy Sak

    $23.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Farm Friends Sassy Sak w/White Hen

    Farm Friends Sassy Sak w/White Hen

    $23.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Large Carl Corgi Muzzle

    Large Carl Corgi Muzzle

    $18.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | LITTLE Cat Pet Plush

    LITTLE Cat Pet Plush

    $8.99
    Go To Product

    Great for ages 3-6

  • Tomfoolery Toys | Oscar Meyer Hot Dog Plush

    Oscar Meyer Hot Dog Plush

    $54.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Bright Lil' Bitty Bunnies

    Bright Lil' Bitty Bunnies

    $9.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Munchie Pink Caterpillar

    Munchie Pink Caterpillar

    $23.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Bessie Brown Cow

    Bessie Brown Cow

    $15.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Large Craig Capybara Muzzle

    Large Craig Capybara Muzzle

    $18.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Cheez-It Plush

    Cheez-It Plush

    $39.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Flyer Firefly Flashlight

    Flyer Firefly Flashlight

    $22.99
    Go To Product

    Great for ages 3-6

  • Tomfoolery Toys | Orie White Owl Soft

    Orie White Owl Soft

    $22.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Burnie Dragon Soft

    Burnie Dragon Soft

    $29.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Jumbo Boots Cat

    Jumbo Boots Cat

    $97.00
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Korner DLux Tri-Color Corgi

    Korner DLux Tri-Color Corgi

    $40.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Lucky Charms Plush

    Lucky Charms Plush

    $38.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Pollen Bumble Bee Sshlumpie

    Pollen Bumble Bee Sshlumpie

    $22.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Cowgirl Chicken

    Cowgirl Chicken

    $18.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Dancin' Pups Sassy Sak w/Golden

    Dancin' Pups Sassy Sak w/Golden

    $23.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Cheetos Flamin Hot Plush

    Cheetos Flamin Hot Plush

    $39.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Valentines Flip Frog w/ Strawberry

    Valentines Flip Frog w/ Strawberry

    $14.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Valentine Teddy Bear

    Valentine Teddy Bear

    $18.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | T-Rex Hand Puppet 12

    T-Rex Hand Puppet 12"

    $19.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Cora Aqua Mermaid Doll

    Cora Aqua Mermaid Doll

    $24.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Crunchie Blue Caterpillar

    Crunchie Blue Caterpillar

    $23.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Just One Me - Sibling Kit

    Just One Me - Sibling Kit

    $37.99
    Go To Product

    Great for ages 3-6

  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Dennie Duck Soft

    Dennie Duck Soft

    $23.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Dachshund Bag Charm

    Dachshund Bag Charm

    $14.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Lemmie Lemur Soft

    Lemmie Lemur Soft

    $25.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Romie Rooster

    Romie Rooster

    $15.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Wrangler Horse

    Wrangler Horse

    $24.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Howie Horseshoe Crab

    Howie Horseshoe Crab

    $19.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Levi Brown Spotted Pig

    Levi Brown Spotted Pig

    $40.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Bouncie Spotted Bunny Soft

    Bouncie Spotted Bunny Soft

    $23.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Cloudie Super Soft Bunny

    Cloudie Super Soft Bunny

    $44.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Ginnie Cream Goose Soft

    Ginnie Cream Goose Soft

    $23.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Highland Cow Bag Charm

    Highland Cow Bag Charm

    $14.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Dragon Bag Charm

    Dragon Bag Charm

    $14.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Striper Skunk

    Striper Skunk

    $14.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Natches Paint Horse

    Natches Paint Horse

    $53.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Cayenne Phoenix

    Cayenne Phoenix

    $31.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Pig Muzzle XL

    Pig Muzzle XL

    $76.00
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Toad 9

    Toad 9" Soft Toy

    $27.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Baby Oink

    Baby Oink

    $22.00
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Chance Boxer

    Chance Boxer

    $40.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Tim Tan Dog Muzzle Extra Large

    Tim Tan Dog Muzzle Extra Large

    $76.00
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Large Frank Fox Muzzle

    Large Frank Fox Muzzle

    $18.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Japanese Tree Frog 8

    Japanese Tree Frog 8"

    $11.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Gabbie French Bulldog Soft

    Gabbie French Bulldog Soft

    $21.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Sweetie Rainbow Bunny Soft

    Sweetie Rainbow Bunny Soft

    $23.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Laddie Flower Highland Cow Mini

    Laddie Flower Highland Cow Mini

    $16.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Large Hank Highland Cow Muzzle

    Large Hank Highland Cow Muzzle

    $18.99
    Go To Product

    Great for ages 10-11

  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Henrietta Blue Lace Hen

    Henrietta Blue Lace Hen

    $24.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Taco Microbead Plush

    Taco Microbead Plush

    $26.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Martin Moose Muzzle

    Martin Moose Muzzle

    $12.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Rainbow Fish Soft Toy

    Rainbow Fish Soft Toy

    $28.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Lifesaver Packaging Plush

    Lifesaver Packaging Plush

    $39.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Sour Patch Kids Easter Plush

    Sour Patch Kids Easter Plush

    $30.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Muddy Spotted Bunny

    Muddy Spotted Bunny

    $46.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Mallorie Baby Mallard Mini

    Mallorie Baby Mallard Mini

    $14.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Marnie Taupe Goose Mini

    Marnie Taupe Goose Mini

    $14.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Capybara Bag Charm

    Capybara Bag Charm

    $14.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Axolotl Bag Charm

    Axolotl Bag Charm

    $14.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Turtle Bag Charm

    Turtle Bag Charm

    $14.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Octopus Bag Charm

    Octopus Bag Charm

    $14.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Puzzle Dlux Calico Cat

    Puzzle Dlux Calico Cat

    $37.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Huckle Cat Soft Toy & Blue Car

    Huckle Cat Soft Toy & Blue Car

    $28.99
    Go To Product

    Great for ages 3-6

  • Tomfoolery Toys | Bananas Gorilla Soft Toy & Banana Car

    Bananas Gorilla Soft Toy & Banana Car

    $28.99
    Go To Product

    Great for ages 3-6

  • Tomfoolery Toys | Poison Dart Frog 7

    Poison Dart Frog 7"

    $14.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Gray Cozy Cat

    Gray Cozy Cat

    $22.00
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Large Glady Cow Muzzle

    Large Glady Cow Muzzle

    $18.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Molly

    Molly

    $29.00
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Clever Fox

    Clever Fox

    $24.50
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Lena

    Lena

    $29.00
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Bag of Hershey Kisses Packaging Plush

    Bag of Hershey Kisses Packaging Plush

    $48.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Zen Bunny w/ Carrot

    Zen Bunny w/ Carrot

    $15.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Candi Pink Highland Cow Soft

    Candi Pink Highland Cow Soft

    $23.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Millie Yellow Duck w/Sound

    Millie Yellow Duck w/Sound

    $10.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Tyler Gray Bunny

    Tyler Gray Bunny

    $13.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Shiloh Lamb

    Shiloh Lamb

    $12.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Barb Bunny Muzzle

    Barb Bunny Muzzle

    $12.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Snail Bag Charm

    Snail Bag Charm

    $14.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Brandon Backpacker Snail

    Brandon Backpacker Snail

    $15.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Donna Donkey Muzzle

    Donna Donkey Muzzle

    $12.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Demi Dragonfly

    Demi Dragonfly

    $16.99
    Go To Product

    Great for ages 3-8

  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Chaz Floppy Chicken

    Chaz Floppy Chicken

    $31.99
    Go To Product
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Buzz Honeybee

    Buzz Honeybee

    $15.99
    Go To Product

    Great for ages 3-12

  • Tomfoolery Toys | Anna the Mouse

    Anna the Mouse

    $50.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Small Nini the Mouse

    Small Nini the Mouse

    $25.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Lowly Worm Soft Toy & Apple Car

    Lowly Worm Soft Toy & Apple Car

    $28.99
    Go To Product

    Great for ages 3-6

  • Tomfoolery Toys | Sweet Dalia

    Sweet Dalia

    $29.00
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Sweet Karolina

    Sweet Karolina

    $29.00
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Easter Sour Patch Kid w/ Bunny Ears

    Easter Sour Patch Kid w/ Bunny Ears

    $18.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Bristle Hedgehog

    Bristle Hedgehog

    $21.99
    Go To Product
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Kool-Aid Plush

    Kool-Aid Plush

    $40.99
    Go To Product
Find out about new deals whenever they happen.