Plush

Browse All Plush

  • Tomfoolery Toys | Brambling Pig

    Regular price $27.50
  • New!
    Out of Stock
    Tomfoolery Toys | PBJ's - Plush Ball Jellies

    Regular price $8.99 $4.49
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Forest Fauna Bear

    Regular price $32.50
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Brambling Mouse

    Regular price $27.50
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Wild Turkey

    Regular price $13.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Santa Claus Gnome Nick

    Regular price $9.99 $5.00
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Sour Patch Kid Plush

    Regular price $23.99

    Great for ages 5-12

  • Out of Stock
    Tomfoolery Toys | Mini Sour Patch Kids Plush

    Regular price $15.99
  • New!
    Out of Stock
    Tomfoolery Toys | Large M & M Plush

    Regular price $31.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Chill Cuddle Pal: Cotton Candy 36

    Regular price $62.00

    Great for ages 5-12

  • Tomfoolery Toys | Bert the Ladybug

    Regular price $13.99

    Great for ages 3-12

  • Tomfoolery Toys | Bonnie Bunny w/ Egg

    Regular price $23.50
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Pandaroll Silver Kisses Plush Blanket

    Regular price $15.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Amuseable Coffee-To-Go Bag

    Regular price $35.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Smillow in Tote Bag

    Regular price $26.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Myrtle Hippopotamus

    Regular price $40.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Large Bumpas

    Regular price $44.99

    Great for ages 5-12

  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Freya Pony

    Regular price $60.00
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Texas State Plush Doll

    Regular price $19.99

    Great for ages 1-12

  • Tomfoolery Toys | Good Night Monster Book & Plush Set

    Regular price $37.99

    Great for ages 3-6

  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Sweater French Bulldog

    Regular price $32.50
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Rosie the Kitten

    Regular price $16.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Frannie the Fox

    Regular price $16.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Winter Warner Munro Scottie

    Regular price $32.50
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Horse Puppet

    Regular price $22.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | 5

    Regular price $8.50
  • New!
    Out of Stock
    Tomfoolery Toys | Pet Carrier

    Regular price $15.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Wren Snowflake Moth

    Regular price $16.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Super Soft Pinkie Pig

    Regular price $36.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Holiday Sugar Cookie Assortment Plush

    Regular price $10.99 $5.50
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | SOS Fun Size Candy Plush

    Regular price $12.99

    Great for ages 11-12

  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Pet Mallows

    Regular price $3.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Rubi Ornament Plush

    Regular price $8.50 $4.25
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Christmas Gizmo

    Regular price $37.50
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Snuggle Nugget Kitty

    Regular price $40.99

    Great for ages 1-6

  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Grandpa Sailor Little Mouse Doll

    Regular price $16.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Julia Little Mouse Doll

    Regular price $16.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Sam's Mother Little Mouse Doll

    Regular price $16.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Ella Little Mouse Doll

    Regular price $16.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Sam Little Mouse Doll

    Regular price $16.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Skittles Plush Pillow

    Regular price $38.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Misfittens Cats

    Regular price $15.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Cosmo Monster

    Regular price $32.50
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Amuseable Potted Bamboo

    Regular price $50.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Munro Scottie Dog - Huge

    Regular price $75.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Spudster Morty Moose

    Regular price $20.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | The Triplets Little Mouse Dolls

    Regular price $30.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Peanut M&M Mini Microbead Plush

    Regular price $17.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Bertie Blue Bird

    Regular price $10.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Bria Butterfly Snuggler

    Regular price $16.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Warrior Appaloosa Horse

    Regular price $12.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Rudie Raccoon Mini Soft

    Regular price $14.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Britt Butterfly Finger Puppet

    Regular price $16.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Moses Terrier Mutt

    Regular price $39.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Pauline Spotted Pig

    Regular price $28.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Finnie Frog

    Regular price $20.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Elodie White Unicorn Mini Soft

    Regular price $13.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Festival Dragon

    Regular price $55.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Snow Dragon Bag Charm

    Regular price $28.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Slick Snake 8

    Regular price $9.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Sour Patch Kids Packaging Plush

    Regular price $42.99

    Great for ages 11-12

  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Frosted Cookie Pets Plush

    Regular price $42.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Spudster Mipaloo Monster

    Regular price $20.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Spudster Lori Ladybug

    Regular price $20.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Spudster Bubblegum Unicorn

    Regular price $20.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Bebe Bugs

    Regular price $14.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | 15

    Regular price $11.99

    Great for ages 5-10

  • Tomfoolery Toys | French Fry Plushie

    Regular price $21.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Santa Ricky Rain Frog

    Regular price $36.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Nesting Chickies

    Regular price $35.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Smudge Rabbit

    Regular price $35.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Bashful Viola Bunny

    Regular price $28.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Messenger Bunny

    Regular price $32.50
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Amore Bunny

    Regular price $40.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Brynlee Bee

    Regular price $28.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Dainty Dessert Bunny Cupcake

    Regular price $28.00
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Amuseable Ramen

    Regular price $40.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Stuffed Walking Easter Character Puppet

    Regular price $3.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Amuseable Sun Huge

    Regular price $60.00
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Backpack Bunny

    Regular price $30.00
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Backpack Elephant

    Regular price $30.00
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Backpack Unicorn

    Regular price $30.00
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Amuseable Watermelon Bag

    Regular price $35.00
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Amuseable Rainbow Bag

    Regular price $40.00
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Amuseable Sun Bag

    Regular price $35.00
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Albert Jack Russell

    Regular price $30.00
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Backpack Puppy

    Regular price $30.00
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Barn Owling

    Regular price $15.00
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Backpack Wolf

    Regular price $30.00
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Sweetiscle Bunny

    Regular price $20.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Little Maya Octopus

    Regular price $30.00
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Daphne Pomeranian

    Regular price $33.00
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Ricky Rain Frog Large

    Regular price $60.00
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Enzo Bear

    Regular price $32.50
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Ricky Rain Frog

    Regular price $28.00
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Maple Bear Medium

    Regular price $28.50

    Great for ages 1-4

  • Tomfoolery Toys | Bashful Puppy Medium

    Regular price $28.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Carey Calf Medium

    Regular price $35.00
  • New!
    New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | With My Dog

    Regular price $37.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Just One Me - Sibling Kit

    Regular price $37.99

    Great for ages 3-6

  • Tomfoolery Toys | Oreo Cookies Packaging Plush

    Regular price $38.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Sour Patch Kids Mini Microbead Plush

    Regular price $17.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Maddie - White Bunny Softie

    Regular price $20.99

    Great for ages 3-12

  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Millie Duck w/ Sound

    Regular price $9.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Out of This World Fleece Plush

    Regular price $35.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Honeyhome Bee

    Regular price $35.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Cheeks Bunny

    Regular price $12.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Dollie Lamb

    Regular price $20.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Farm Friends Sassy Sak w/ White Hen

    Regular price $21.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Flint Firefly

    Regular price $16.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Mini Butterfly

    Regular price $11.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Foxiroll Red Kisses Plush Blanket (Mini)

    Regular price $10.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Cow Kittiroll Plush Blanket

    Regular price $14.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Velveteen Frog

    Regular price $32.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Velveteen Dinos

    Regular price $29.99

    Great for ages 1-2

  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Lyle, Lyle Crocodile

    Regular price $13.99

    Great for ages 1-4

  • Tomfoolery Toys | Sourpuss Octopus

    Regular price $32.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Perrie Penguin Mini Soft

    Regular price $13.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Carmine Cardinal

    Regular price $10.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Zoinkie Spotted Pig

    Regular price $21.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Nectar Hummingbird

    Regular price $10.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Sour Patch Kid Plush Blind Bag

    Regular price $7.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Starsky Appaloosa Horse

    Regular price $22.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Tumbleweed Bull

    Regular price $14.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Boho Horseshoe Sak w/ Chestnut Horse

    Regular price $21.99

    Great for ages 1-6

  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Ned Narwhal

    Regular price $18.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Freckles Golden Appaloosa Foal

    Regular price $17.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Ricardo Rooster

    Regular price $28.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Corey Paige Hearts Mini Backpack

    Regular price $40.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Corey Paige Hearts Plush Shorts

    Regular price $24.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Corey Paige Sleeping Bag

    Regular price $71.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Amuseable Sun Bag Charm

    Regular price $25.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Little Pig Bag

    Regular price $40.00
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Backpack Panda

    Regular price $30.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Amuseable Sports Table Tennis

    Regular price $33.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Clyde Capybara

    Regular price $43.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Gordy Guinea Pig

    Regular price $30.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Little Pup Bag

    Regular price $40.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Straw-Beret Sallie

    Regular price $23.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Wanderlust Puppy

    Regular price $100.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Wanderlust Elly

    Regular price $100.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Infinity Flipper

    Regular price $10.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | 14

    Regular price $30.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Harper the Bunny

    Regular price $72.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Goldie the Honey Bear

    Regular price $72.00
  • New!
    Out of Stock
    Tomfoolery Toys | Hannah the Bunny

    Regular price $72.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Carissa Persian Cat

    Regular price $45.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Yummy Puppy

    Regular price $20.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Little Pig Bag Charm

    Regular price $25.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Amuseable Chili Pepper

    Regular price $23.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Amuseable Storm Cloud

    Regular price $29.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Little Pup Bag Charm

    Regular price $25.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Baker Little Mouse Doll

    Regular price $18.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Extra Large Soft Stuffed Baryonx

    Regular price $25.99

    Great for ages 3-6

  • Tomfoolery Toys | Extra Large Soft Stuffed Triceratops

    Regular price $25.99

    Great for ages 3-6

  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Extra Large Soft Stuffed Crocodile

    Regular price $25.99

    Great for ages 3-6

  • Tomfoolery Toys | Egg-stra Cute Chick Basket Plush

    Regular price $36.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Too Sweet Bunny Basket Plush

    Regular price $36.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Amuseable Rainbow Birthday Cake

    Regular price $60.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Amuseable Coffee Bean

    Regular price $23.00
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Tiger Tayto 6

    Regular price $16.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Bartholomew Bear Huge

    Regular price $55.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Amuseable Coffee Cup

    Regular price $28.00
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Alice Axolotl

    Regular price $32.50
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Amuseable Golf Ball

    Regular price $22.00
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Fun-Guy Robbie

    Regular price $23.00
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Amuseable Tennis Ball

    Regular price $27.50
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Fun-Guy Ozzie

    Regular price $23.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Bunny Chicks Plush

    Regular price $16.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Amuseable Peanut

    Regular price $20.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Caboodle Puppy

    Regular price $20.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Dara Giraffe

    Regular price $75.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Randall Basset Hound

    Regular price $35.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Richie Dromedary

    Regular price $60.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Dainty Dessert Bunny Macaron

    Regular price $28.00
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Amuseable Baseball

    Regular price $27.50
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Smudge Elephant Large

    Regular price $75.00

    Great for ages 1-4

  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Pandaroll Sitting Plush (Medium)

    Regular price $19.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Kittiroll Sitting Plush (Medium)

    Regular price $19.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Blue Dragon Mint Kittiroll Sitting Plush (Medium)

    Regular price $21.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Flower Basket Bunniroll Plush (Small)

    Regular price $15.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Bunniroll Plush (Medium)

    Regular price $20.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Smarties Plush

    Regular price $34.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Sour Skittles Fleece Plush

    Regular price $42.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Dum-Dums Plush

    Regular price $42.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Chips Ahoy Plush

    Regular price $42.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Baseball 3D Plush

    Regular price $18.99

    Great for ages 5-12

  • Tomfoolery Toys | Mini Furry Sour Patch Kid Plush

    Regular price $15.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Dario Donkey

    Regular price $60.00
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Andie Axolotl

    Regular price $32.50
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Ambrosie Squirrel

    Regular price $35.00
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Featherful Swan

    Regular price $75.00
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Amuseabean Unicorn

    Regular price $20.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Amuseable Oats

    Regular price $40.00
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Caractacus Chameleon

    Regular price $65.00
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Amuseable Slice of Lime

    Regular price $32.50
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Amuseable Bubble Tea

    Regular price $28.00
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Nudge Horse

    Regular price $22.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Lia Ladybug Sshlumpie

    Regular price $22.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Pollen Bumble Bee Sshlumpie

    Regular price $22.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Austin Armadillo

    Regular price $23.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Baby Cuddle Hug Fox

    Regular price $26.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Bumble Bee Playtivity Rattle

    Regular price $13.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Hemie Spot Horse Soft

    Regular price $21.99
  • New!
    Tomfoolery Toys | Lia Ladybug Playtivity Rattle

    Regular price $13.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Western Sak w/ Buckskin Horse

    Regular price $21.99
  • Tomfoolery Toys | Smudge Elephant

    Regular price $35.00

    Great for ages 1-4

  • Tomfoolery Toys | Bashful Toffee Puppy Medium

    Regular price $28.00
Find out about new deals whenever they happen.